Create Your Own Cookies & Brownie Boxes

Choose Your Own Cookie & Brownie Assortments

Choose from our assortment of best-selling cookie or brownie flavors to create a gift box filled with their favorites. Send your friends and family a gift filled with make your own cookies and brownies they are sure to love. Mix and match the perfect flavors all in one thoughtful box!

Customized Cookie & Brownie Boxes From Cheryl’s Cookies

With our Create Your Own cookies option, you can mix and match flavors, making it a unique experience for all based on their cookie flavor preference. Enjoy crafting your own delectable treat or a heartwarming customized cookie gift for your loved ones. Whether it be our mouthwatering buttercream frosted cookies or soft oatmeal raisin, you can discover the joy of Cheryl’s Cookies in every bite!

Frequently Asked Choose Your Own Cookie Questions:

What cookie flavors can I choose?

Create the most delicious array of cookie flavors with a customizable cookie box. Pick from classic chocolate chip, triple chocolate frosted, snickerdoodle, oatmeal raisin and so much more! If you or your loved one have dietary restrictions, grab a sugar free cookie box. The same delicious cookie flavors with less sugar will bring a smile to anyone’s face.

Why create your own cookie box?

Create your own cookie box so you have all your favorite cookie flavors in one gift! Whether you’re sending it as a gift or treating yourself, creating your own cookie box is a great way to enjoy classic cookie types and try new ones. No guessing or hoping your favorite flavors will be included, you get to choose the cookie types to include to ensure a delicious experience for everyone